My Inventory
Log every piece. Track value. Build the vault.
0
Pieces
$0
Collection Value
$0
Avg Value
Marketplace
Post what you're selling or hunting. Local board for now.
Restoration Guide
Five proven methods. Read safety before you start.
Lye Bath
What it does
Strips old seasoning and carbon buildup. Does NOT remove rust.
Materials
100% lye crystals (1 lb), 5-gallon plastic bucket, water, rubber gloves, eye protection.
Steps
- Fill bucket with cold water.
- Slowly add lye to water (NEVER water to lye).
- Submerge piece.
- Wait 3–7 days.
- Scrub with steel wool.
- Rinse thoroughly.
- Dry immediately.
Safety
Caustic. Gloves + eye protection mandatory. Keep away from children/pets. Neutralize spills with vinegar.
Best for
Pieces with thick old seasoning, crud, carbon buildup. Safe to leave indefinitely.
Electrolysis Tank
What it does
Removes rust AND seasoning. Most thorough method.
Materials
Manual battery charger (10+ amp), plastic tub, washing soda (not baking soda), scrap steel (anode), wire, clamps.
Steps
- Mix washing soda in water (1 tbsp per gallon).
- Connect NEGATIVE lead to the cast iron piece.
- Connect POSITIVE lead to scrap steel anode.
- Keep anode and piece separate — no touching.
- Run 12–24 hours.
- Scrub, rinse, dry immediately.
Safety
Produces hydrogen gas — use in a ventilated area. No sparks or flames near the tank.
Best for
Heavy rust, multiple pieces, complete restoration.
Vinegar Bath
What it does
Removes light to moderate rust. Does NOT remove seasoning.
Materials
White vinegar, water, plastic tub, steel wool.
Steps
- Mix 50/50 vinegar and water.
- Submerge piece.
- Soak 30 minutes.
- Scrub with steel wool.
- Repeat if needed.
- Rinse thoroughly.
- Dry immediately.
- Oil immediately — flash rust forms fast.
Safety
Mild. Use in a ventilated area.
Best for
Light surface rust, quick clean-up between uses. NOT for heavy rust or valuable antiques (can etch the surface).
Oven Cleaner Method
What it does
Strips seasoning using spray oven cleaner. Beginner-friendly.
Materials
Easy-Off Heavy Duty (yellow cap, with lye), trash bags, rubber gloves, eye protection.
Steps
- Spray piece heavily in a well-ventilated area.
- Seal in a trash bag.
- Wait 24–72 hours.
- Scrub with steel wool.
- Rinse thoroughly.
- Repeat if needed.
Safety
Contains lye. Gloves, eye protection, ventilation. Keep the bag sealed.
Best for
Beginners. A single piece. No dedicated setup space.
Seasoning
What it does
Polymerized oil coating. Protective, non-stick surface.
Materials
Crisco, grapeseed oil, or flaxseed oil. Paper towels. Oven.
Steps
- Strip piece bare.
- Dry completely.
- Apply a THIN coat of oil — wipe it off like you made a mistake (excess = sticky).
- Place upside-down in a COLD oven.
- Heat to 450–500°F.
- Bake 1 hour.
- Turn off oven, let cool inside.
- Repeat 3–4 times.
Safety
Oil smoke point matters. Ventilate. Don't use olive oil (smoke point too low).
Best for
Every piece after restoration. Canola/Crisco for durability, grapeseed for appearance, flaxseed for hardness (but it can flake).
Do's
- Strip before seasoning. Always.
- Thin coats. Multiple layers. Patience.
- Dry immediately after water contact.
- Test for lead on old smelting/glue pots before cooking use.
- Store in a dry place with the lid slightly ajar for airflow.
Don'ts
- Never use a wire wheel or sandblast — destroys collector value permanently.
- Never put cast iron in a fire to clean it — warps, cracks, ruins temper.
- Never use the self-cleaning oven cycle — too hot, warps pans.
- Never soak in water overnight — rust.
- Never put cold water in a hot pan — thermal shock = crack.
- Never use soap on a seasoned surface (mild soap okay on bare iron before seasoning).
Reference
Brands, types, and the grails worth knowing.
| Brand | Era | Logo / Marks | Value Tier |
|---|---|---|---|
| Griswold | 1865–1957 | Erie, Slant, Block, Small block logos; cross/diamond | High |
| Wagner | 1891–1959 | Wagner Ware Sidney -O-; arched script | High |
| Wapak | 1903–1926 | Indian head logo; "Wapak" | High |
| Favorite Piqua | 1916–1934 | Smiling Indian (Piqua Ware) | Premium |
| Lodge | 1896–present | Vintage: 3-notch/egg logo. Modern: "Lodge USA" | Mid |
| Martin Stove & Range | 1920s–1950s | "Martin"; stylized script | Mid |
| Vollrath | 1900s–1940s | "Vollrath" with pattern numbers | Mid |
| BSR (Birmingham Stove & Range) | 1902–1990s | "Red Mountain", "Century", "Snack" series | Budget |
| CHF (Chicago Hardware Foundry) | 1897–1959 | "CHF"; National brand | Budget |
| Type | Notes |
|---|---|
| Skillet | The workhorse. Sizes #2–#14, by number. |
| Dutch Oven | Lidded pot. Camp (legs) or kitchen (flat). |
| Griddle | Flat round or rectangular. Round/oval handle styles. |
| Waffle Iron | Hinged paired plates, often with base. |
| Corn Stick Pan | Ear-of-corn molds. Collectible patterns. |
| Gem / Muffin Pan | Cup molds; many novelty shapes. |
| Aebleskiver Pan | Hemispherical wells for Danish pancakes. |
| Bread Pan | Loaf or French roll molds. |
| Kettle | Bulbous pot, often with bail handle. |
| Bean Pot | Lidded round-bellied pot. |
| Scotch Bowl | Round-bottomed cooking bowl. |
| Spider Skillet | Footed skillet — the spider-logo Griswolds are grails. |
| Glue Pot | Double-boiler for hide glue. Test for lead before food use. |
| Smelting Pot | Ladle/melting pot. Test for lead before food use. |
| Toy / Replica | Salesman samples and miniatures; reproductions common. |
Rarity & Value Guide
The numbers serious collectors chase.
Griswold #1 Skillet
$1,000+
Tiny size, low production — a key date for the set.
Griswold #13 Skillet
$2,800+
Odd in-between size, scarce survivors.
Spider Logo Skillet
$4,000–$10,000
Erie "spider" trademark — the genre's holy grail.
Griswold #14 Skillet
$3,200+
Large format, hard to find clean and flat.
Gate Mark (pre-1880)
Sprue scar on the bottom = pre-1880 casting. Age premium across all forms.